New York City is full of people who want their estates to support a cause, whether a hospital, a synagogue or church, an alma mater, or a local nonprofit. Generosity is the easy part. Structuring the gift so it survives probate, reduces tax, and reaches the right organization is where plans go wrong. Here are the charitable-giving mistakes to avoid.
Mistake #1: Naming the Charity Vaguely
“I leave $25,000 to the cancer charity” invites a dispute. There are many similarly named nonprofits across NYC and nationally. Use the organization’s full legal name and, ideally, its identifying tax number, so your executor and the Surrogate’s Court are not left guessing or litigating which group you meant.
Mistake #2: Using a Taxable Account When a Retirement Account Is Better
Leaving a traditional IRA or 401(k) to your children means they pay income tax on withdrawals. Charities, by contrast, pay no income tax. A common NYC mistake is gifting cash to charity by will while leaving heavily taxed retirement accounts to family. Reversing that, naming a charity as beneficiary of the retirement account and leaving other assets to heirs, can deliver more to everyone.
Mistake #3: Overlooking the New York Estate Tax Charitable Deduction
Charitable bequests reduce your taxable estate. This matters in New York, where the 2026 estate tax exclusion is $7,350,000 and a sharp “cliff” at $7,717,500 can wipe out the entire exclusion. A well-placed charitable gift can pull a Manhattan estate back under the cliff, protecting far more value than the gift itself. This is precise math worth getting right.
Mistake #4: Putting Charitable Gifts Only in a Will
Gifts made solely through a will must pass through Surrogate’s Court probate (SCPA), which takes time and is public. For some donors, a revocable living trust (EPTL Article 7) can deliver charitable gifts more privately and without probate delay. The trust itself does not save estate tax, but it streamlines distribution to your chosen causes.
Mistake #5: Ignoring Advanced Vehicles When the Gift Is Large
For substantial NYC estates, tools like charitable remainder trusts or a donor-advised fund can provide income or family involvement while still benefiting charity. These are not do-it-yourself instruments. Setting one up incorrectly can forfeit the very tax benefits that justify it.
Mistake #6: Forgetting to Coordinate the Rest of Your Plan
Charitable intentions only work if your foundational documents are sound: a valid will under EPTL §3-2.1, a durable power of attorney (GOL §5-1513), and a health care proxy (PHL Article 29-C). Without them, incapacity or an outdated plan can derail your giving long before any charity sees a dollar.
Consult a New York Attorney
Charitable giving rewards precision. A New York estate planning attorney can name the right organization, choose the right asset, and time the gift to maximize the New York estate tax benefit, so your generosity reaches the NYC causes you care about with the least waste. Talk through your goals before drafting, and your gift will do exactly what you intend.
Have a question about your estate?
Talk it through with Russel Morgan — free 30-minute consult.